Table of Contents
The primary distinction between pre-tax and deductions after taxes is the period when workers must pay taxes on them. Deductions prior to filing a tax return, such as certain retirement contributions and insurance premiums, are monies deducted from an employee’s wages before taxes are calculated, lowering your and your workers’ tax bills. Deductions after taxes are the polar opposite of deductions prior to filing a tax return since they are taken after an employee’s earnings have been taxed.
What Are Pre-Tax and Deductions After Taxes and How Do They Work?
When it’s time to compute payroll, you’ll need to know the total amount of deductions each employee is eligible for, as well as whether they’re pre-tax or post-tax.
Employee A, for example, may have pre-tax health insurance and post-tax child support deductions deducted from their pay, whereas Employee B has a post-tax Roth 401(k) premium and a flexible spending account (FSA) contribution (pre-tax). To figure out how much payroll and income taxes to withhold, multiply the employee’s taxable income by the appropriate percentage (set by the IRS, state, or local agency).
When it comes to payroll deductions, the most frequent error companies make is removing payments at the incorrect time. The payroll tax computation does not take into account Deductions After Taxes. You do not need to lower an employee’s taxable income amount if you deduct money from their check for a post-tax deduction, such as a Roth 401(k) premium. Employees should be taxed on all of their earnings, regardless of how much money is withheld from their paycheck for Deductions After Taxes.
Types of Tax Deductions (Pre- and Post-Tax)
There are several different sorts of payroll deductions that may apply to your paycheck. Some are always pre-tax, while others are either pre-tax or post-tax, depending on the scenario and what your employee decides. Some Deductions Prior to Filing a Tax Return are likewise restricted to a particular amount of benefit. For example, optional life insurance premiums provide a pre-tax benefit of up to $50,000 in benefits; anything above that is taxed.
Deductions Prior to Filing a Tax Return
You may be acquainted with the following pre-tax employee deductions:
- Health insurance: This normally covers medical, dental, and vision coverage; however, certain post-tax choices exist, so be sure to verify before adding these to your benefit package.
- HSAs (health savings accounts) and FSAs (flexible spending accounts): Allows employees to pay for anticipated medical expenses before they occur, allowing them to avoid paying taxes; employers benefit as well because they don’t have to pay Social Security or Medicare tax on money deposited into these accounts.
- Commuter benefits: If they discover a supplier that provides commuter benefit choices, employers may deduct transportation expenditures such as parking garage fees and public transit tickets from employee paychecks on a pre-tax basis.
- Employer-paid life insurance: In terms of FICA and unemployment taxes, employer-paid life insurance premiums are tax-free up to $50,000 in benefits. When it comes to income taxes, there is no limit to the pre-tax amount.
- Pre-tax contributions: Traditional IRAs, 403(b) plans (for organizations), and many 401(k) plans accept pre-tax contributions. Employees, on the other hand, are restricted in how much they may contribute to each plan on a yearly basis, and when they take the money during retirement, they will be subject to taxes. Also, FICA is still applicable, but not income taxes.
Deductions After Taxes
You may be acquainted with the following post-tax employee deductions:
- Roth IRA contributions: Roth IRA contributions are made after-tax monies. Employees won’t have to pay taxes on the money when they withdraw it after retirement.
- Disability insurance: Pre-tax or post-tax cash may be used to obtain disability insurance for which your workers pay the premium. Employees may choose the programs they want to participate in.
- Life insurance premiums: Must be paid after-tax for any life insurance benefits provided exceeding $50,000.
- Garnishments: Examples include student loans in default, child support, and old medical debt; these don’t receive any tax benefit and should be classified as Deductions After Taxes.
Which Is Better: Pre-Tax or Deductions After Taxes?
When your workers begin to consider their benefits alternatives, they may wonder if they should pick pre-tax or post-tax benefits. There is no definitive answer to which is superior.
Some pre-tax benefits, such as retirement contributions, are liable to taxes later, so workers should factor in how much their income is expected to rise over time. Higher income often means higher tax rates. It’s a good idea to make post-tax contributions if an employee anticipates their income to climb considerably over their retirement years. If they foresee it decreasing considerably, they should try paying it using pre-tax cash; they’ll have to pay taxes later, but at a reduced rate.
Keep in mind that future tax rates are impossible to predict. It’s crucial to remember that until the time comes, there’s no way of knowing what they’ll be or how they’ll affect your workers’ pre-tax benefits.
Conclusion
It’s critical to pay attention to the numerous sorts of payroll deductions you’re processing for your workers since each has its own set of tax requirements. When it comes to payroll, knowing the various benefit programs, as well as your state and municipal rules governing specific pre-tax benefits, can save you time. Many payroll deductions may be made either pre-tax or post-tax, so be sure you understand which alternatives your workers prefer.
If you’d rather not worry about what deductions need to be made pre-tax and which are meant to be taken post-tax, consider using a payroll provider like Gusto. You can choose the benefit or deduction needed, and Gusto’s system handles the rest. Once entered into the system, Gusto’s software will deduct all pre-tax and Deductions After Taxes automatically for each period.
