Restaurant Tip Pooling Laws & Guidelines

Table of Contents

The tip pooling laws vary by jurisdiction, but the basic principle is that some percentage of service charges are redistributed to wait staff as a form of compensation for their efforts. Waiters and waitresses will often receive around 15-25% in tips from each customer after taxes have been calculated into their total compensation. The issue with this type of law is it leaves no incentive for servers to provide better services or improve on their game – which means customers might not get what they deserve

The “new tip law 2021” is a new law that will go into effect on January 1st, 2021. The law will require employers to share tips with employees who make less than $30/hour.

Tip pooling is the process of pooling all or a part of your workers’ tips and distributing them to qualified front-of-house (FOH) personnel. Tip pooling, which is sometimes mistaken with tip sharing, which generally includes staff who do not earn tips, may boost morale. However, there are rules that must be obeyed in order to avoid being punished, such as those prohibiting management involvement.

Consider Gusto if you need a means to track and disburse cash and credit card tips to workers who pool their tips. Taxes will be withheld (and submitted) and direct payments will be executed after you select how much to disburse among workers and input it into the program. For 30 days, you may try it for free.

Gusto is a great place to visit.

What is Tip Pooling and How Does It Work?

To comprehend tip pooling, you must first understand what a tip is.

A tip is a voluntary sum of money provided by a client to compensate employees for their services, according to the IRS. It’s money paid on top of ordinary pay that’s taxed if it’s more than $20 per month.

Tip pooling may be done in a variety of ways. Tipped workers often collect all cash tips received during their shift and mix them with tips from other employees working the same shift. After the tips have been tallied, the employer or workers split them equitably among tip pool members. If there is enough cash on hand, tips collected via credit or debit card may be disbursed the same night (if there is enough cash on hand) or paid with the following paycheck.

The Department of Labor (DOL) attempted to implement a 2018 FLSA modification allowing back-of-house (BOH) staff, such as cooks and dishwashers, to participate in tip pools in December 2020. As long as you pay all of your workers at least the federal minimum wage rate of $7.25 per hour, you may include BOH employees in your tip pooling scheme. This is on pause since we now have a new executive administration. Stay tuned for further information.

When BOH staff combine their tips, it isn’t always an equitable split. The majority of allocations are based on a proportion of sales or a percentage per job title. Servers typically get the majority of the traffic, at least 70%—but it may be as low as 50%. The following is an example tip pooling setup in percentages:

Employers are urged to require their FOH personnel to exchange tips with BOH staff through the tip pool beginning April 31, 2021. However, there is currently no formal guideline on how much servers should be required to pay out, so it’s a good idea to have a framework in place. If your workers form their own tip pool, they may choose how much to disperse and with whom they wish to split it.

Before we proceed on What is Tip Pooling and How Does It Work?, let us first define a couple more key terms.

Tipped workers are individuals who get more than $30 in gratuities per month on a regular basis, as defined by the FLSA.
Tip credit: According to federal law, this amount is $5.12, which is the difference between the federal minimum wage ($7.25 per hour) and what employers are permitted to pay tipped workers ($2.13), assuming they get enough tips to cover the difference. If the tips aren’t enough, the employer must cover the difference. However, Alaska, California, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington are among the states that do not offer tip credit.

Laws on Tip Pooling

Although the federal government is working to change tip pooling policies, several states have yet to do so. Alaska, California, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington, for example, were automatically given permission to include BOH workers in their tip pooling arrangements since they already had legislation against paying tipped employees below minimum wage. This is due to the fact that all employees in the institution were already paid at least minimum wage, which is a prerequisite for restaurateurs who want non-tipped employees to split tips.

Federal Laws on Tip Pooling

Apart from who is allowed to join a tip pool, the DOL has additional restrictions that you should be aware of in order to avoid responsibility. It’s critical to remember that all gratuities (not service charges) are the property of your staff. Even if you pay your restaurant with a credit or debit card, you are not allowed to retain any of the tips for yourself or your company. You’re also not authorized to pool them and give them to any supervisory staff.

In terms of pooling advice, there are a few hard and fast principles to follow:

Advise workers: Before tipped employees participate, you must notify them of any mandatory tip pool contribution amounts and to whom they will be allocated. It’s a good idea to have a standard notification on hand to give out when someone is hired.
Employers are banned from keeping workers’ gratuities for any reason other than authenticating or processing with their next payment. All tips are the workers’ property.
Managers and supervisors are specifically prohibited from participating in a tip pool under any circumstances.
Require a fair contribution amount: You can’t have workers pay more than is normal and acceptable into the tip pool. The DOL first defined this as 15% of tips received or 2% of daily sales in 2011, but there are no strict guidelines since a maximum contribution level has yet to be determined. Many restaurant staff earn more than 15%.

State Laws on Tip Pooling

Although the final rule revising the tip employee regulation has already been released and scheduled to be implemented April 31, 2021, Laws on Tip Pooling still vary widely by state. This rule will have little effect on the 43 states that allow restaurants to claim a tip credit.

Changes to the 80/20 rule or the dual occupations law, on the other hand, will have a greater effect on restaurant owners. The employer was required to pay the legal minimum wage instead of a tip credit if the tipped employee completed both tipped and non-tipped labor that made up more than 20% of their work hours. Employers will be able to claim tip credit after the new rule takes effect, as long as non-tipped labor was allocated promptly before or after tip-producing responsibilities.

The new federal regulation will not be a problem in California and Arizona since they allow you to add BOH and FOH staff to a tip pool, while Minnesota forbids it entirely. According to New York State, only FOH personnel are eligible to participate.

“must conduct, or help in providing, personal service to guests at a level that is a main and regular element of their job and is not just occasional or incidental,” according to the law, adding that only “food service employees may receive distributions from the tip pool.”

Employers may enroll BOH workers in the tip pool since Oregon and many other states do not have explicit requirements for tip pooling. Some states, such as Washington, have taken the initiative and adopted a policy to provide much-needed direction to companies. The state legislation does not define which workers may be included in a tip pool, according to Washington State’s current regulation, with the exception that individuals who do not fulfill the criteria of an employee are not permitted to join.

Since a restaurant owner, the best course of action is to get advice from your state’s labor department, as law is likely to change, and you don’t want to be caught off guard and face penalties. Better better, get a legal advisor to ensure that you are according to the requirements.

Consequences of Not Complying With Laws on Tip Pooling

Common violations employers make with regard to tip pooling regulations are including ineligible employees in a required tip pool and not paying employees all tips received. Per the DOL, if you violate any federal Laws on Tip Pooling, you’ll have to pay the employees back for any tips they were owed but didn’t receive, tip credits claimed, and an additional amount for liquidated damages.

Keep in mind that the amendment that allows BOH employees to join in the tip pool is pending. If you violate Laws on Tip Pooling at the state level in addition to federal, you’ll likely owe additional penalties.

Consider Lightspeed Restaurant if you need a solution to keep track of sales and tips in order to avoid hefty penalties. It allows your personnel to clock in and out, handle orders, and monitor tips with ease. It also works with Homebase time management software and Gusto payroll software to help you optimize your payroll process. Tips that have been pooled may be easily monitored, recorded, taxed, and paid.

Lightspeed Restaurant is worth a visit.

Tip Sharing vs. Tip Pooling

The distinction between tip pooling and tip sharing will become less evident if federal law amendments regarding tip pooling are enacted. Tip sharing is a practice in which tipped staff share part of their tips with BOH employees, despite the fact that many people use the terms interchangeably. Many restaurants used to be prohibited from requiring this form of distribution when pooling tips, although restaurateurs often urged their waiters to do so at their discretion. Traditionally, tip pooling has been limited to front-of-house personnel.

Restaurants that pay at least minimum wage will be allowed to require that BOH staff be reimbursed from pooling agreements under the 2018 final amendment. On a federal level, this blurs the boundary between tip pooling and tip sharing. “Employers who pay the full Federal Labor Standards Act (FLSA) minimum wage are no longer prohibited from allowing employees who are not customarily and regularly tipped—such as cooks and dishwashers—to participate in tip pools,” according to the DOL’s guidance, which makes no distinction between the two.

Many states’ laws still prohibit restaurants from requiring tipped staff to split tips with BOH employees, making the distinction between tip pooling and tip sharing more clear. It’s also worth noting that in order for employee tips to be pooled, all or a part of them must be put together before being distributed. In the past, many servers who contributed tips with BOH personnel did so out of their own pockets, rather than pooling them.

It’s helpful to know the distinctions between tip pooling and tip sharing, as well as their history, so you’re not confused when new federal and state law is implemented.

Check read our post on tip outs to learn more about the many forms of tips.

Participating Employees in Tip Pooling

When creating a tip pooling program for your restaurant, you must first determine which roles are eligible (and those you have to exclude). According to the amendment we’re waiting on, both tipped and non-tipped workers are allowed to participate in tip pooling (as long as their employers pay them at least the federal minimum wage).

Restaurant owners, managers, and supervisors, as well as business partners who control at least 20% of the firm, are specifically forbidden from splitting gratuities with staff. Owners should have minimal control on tips and should only be able to:

Distribute tips to the staff who got them as soon as possible (no later than the next pay period following the data they are received)
Staff should be required to exchange tips with other eligible employees.
By the next scheduled paycheck, organize tip pooling by collecting and allocating tips to qualified workers in a tip pool.

Alternatives to Tip Pooling That Isn’t Required

Alternatives should be considered to eliminate the legal complexity connected with forced tip sharing, as well as some of the downsides. Determine why you want to enact a required policy first. Increased salaries for BOH personnel, ensuring that all tipped employees are compensated for their service regardless of how highly their clients tipped, and reducing arguing over select customers are all common causes.

Here are some Alternatives to Tip Pooling That Isn’t Required that you should consider.

Wages for BOH employees should be increased.

Consider boosting hourly rates for BOH personnel on a regular basis if you want to close the salary gap between FOH staff, such as waiters, and BOH staff. The fact that BOH workers’ earnings do not change, which means they do not raise as much as tipped employees’ wages, is a source of frustration for them. BOH staff are more likely to stay motivated if you provide performance increases or incentives.

Consider taking advantage of the tip credit if you’re concerned about how regular salary increases may effect your Conclusion. You may pay tipped workers as little as $2.13 an hour under federal law, as long as they get enough tips (individually and via a proper tip pooling system) to earn the $7.25 hourly minimum wage.

Keep in mind that once you choose the tip credit, you won’t be able to go back to forcing FOH staff to pool or split tips with BOH personnel; it must be an option.

Encourage and educate employees on voluntary tip pooling.

If you oblige your workers to pay their tips into a pool that will be dispersed, you are using mandatory tip pooling. Tipp pooling is similar to voluntary tip pooling, except it is totally organized by the employees. They may ask if you’d want to assist by distributing via payroll or counting and giving it out in cash, as you would if it were obligatory, and it’s up to you to decide if you’re willing to do so.

Because this is a volunteer setting, you have no influence in how tips are gathered or dispersed. Because tips are given to your restaurant, you have control over how promptly you pay them out (though the following pay period is the latest you’re authorized to pay). You still have no say in who gets what and how much.

In this case, you may still take advantage of the tip credit and ensure that your BOH staff gets tips if workers want to do so. The key to creating a valid voluntary tip pooling system is to ensure that it is sufficiently portrayed that workers were not coerced or forced into it. You might have them sign a statement stating that their choice to form a tip pooling arrangement was not influenced by you.

Conclusion

Laws on Tip Pooling can be confusing due to the new federal amendment allowing BOH employees to participate, and the various state laws that allow or prohibit are unclear, or don’t express an opinion on the matter. Ensuring you follow all rules may require a legal adviser; otherwise, you can be charged thousands of dollars for violations.

Because workers who participate in tip pools are obligated to submit their tips, payroll software like Gusto can make it simple. It allows you to record and tax cash tips as well as add credit card tips to workers’ paychecks. Today is the last day to sign up for a free 30-day trial.