In-House Fulfillment vs Fulfillment Center: Ultimate Guide

Over the past few years, in-house fulfillment has become more and more popular. As companies look to reduce their delivery costs better than ever before however, some are starting to question whether there is a place for these operations now that they can easily outsource their deliveries through third party providers.

The “how much does it cost to open a fulfillment center” is an in-house fulfillment vs. fulfillment center. This article will give you all the information you need to know about these two different options for your business.

Receiving items, holding inventory, processing orders, packaging them for shipping, and delivering them to the consumer are all part of ecommerce order fulfillment. It requires a significant amount of time and money.

Businesses may either fulfill orders in-house (or at a leased facility) or outsource the process to a fulfillment center managed by a third-party supplier.

• For firms that handle less than 10 orders per day, in-house fulfillment is the best option.
• For firms that execute more than 10 orders per day, third-party fulfillment is the best option.

When you’re completing more than 10 ecommerce orders per day, outsourcing your fulfillment to a third party may save you time and money. Continue reading for a complete cost breakdown and an explanation of the two fulfillment methods:

Which Is Better For Your Company?

For most companies that ship 10 or more orders per day, collaborating with a fulfillment provider may save you money and give you more time to focus on growing your business. However, since each choice has its own set of advantages, it’s a good idea to weigh the prospective costs and rewards carefully.

The cost and benefit differences between in-house and outsourced order fulfillment may be summarized in two words: cost and benefit. Later on, we’ll go into the specifics of those issues.

Take a look at the ins and outs of each fulfillment method before deciding which is ideal for your company.

What Is In-House Fulfillment and How Does It Work?

With this form of operation, your company is in charge of every step of the process of fulfilling your clients’ purchases. You’ll need enough storage space and bandwidth to accept, process, ship, and service orders, as well as enough bandwidth to receive, process, ship, and serve them.

Many companies and new internet shops operate out of the owner’s house, in a living room, guest bedroom, or garage.

Owners often relocate their in-house fulfillment facilities to an external site when their firm grows and order volume surpasses available capacity. Although renting a storage facility is a popular and cost-effective choice, higher-volume vendors often lease their own industrial warehouse.

Similarly, fulfillment on a small scale can normally be handled by one person, but as the firm expands, owners often engage employees to help with the process.

Although packing boxes and delivering orders seems to be a straightforward task, there are several considerations that must be considered. In addition to the fundamentals, you’ll need to think about:

• Rent/Lease
• Insurance
• Labor
• Utilities
• Supplies
• Geographical distributions
• Variations in the seasons

In-house fulfillment is perfect for small firms that only handle a few orders per day and have a local consumer base.

What is the Process of a Third-Party Order Fulfillment Company?

Fulfillment may be outsourced to a specialised provider by ecommerce retailers, wholesalers, and other merchants. These organizations receive, sort, and store your product in warehouses that are strategically positioned.

Your orders are sent to the fulfillment firm through an internet portal as they come in. Most suppliers can link with your marketplaces to route orders automatically, or you can manually input them.

The fulfillment team selects the requested items from inventory, prepares them for shipping, and dispatches them. Most third-party logistics (3PL) organizations provide far better shipping costs than you could obtain on your own, thanks to volume discounts and long-standing business connections with carriers.

Customers may ship undesired product straight to the fulfillment center, where it will be handled according to your standards, provided your store’s return policy permits it. Whitebox and FBA, for example, will even handle support requests from your customers, earning them slots in our fulfillment business buyer’s guide.

Growing ecommerce firms that handle more than 10 orders per day may consider outsourcing fulfillment to an order fulfillment provider. In most cases, firms will begin completing orders in-house and later outsource whenever available space and staff exceed demand.

You’ll need to consider your money as well as your goals, such as control, distribution efficiency, scalability, industry knowledge, and time, to figure out which choice is ideal for your company.

Begin by calculating the costs of each fulfillment plan.

How to Calculate the Costs of In-House Fulfillment

The cost of in-house fulfillment will vary depending on the amount of orders and products offered by your shop, as well as the fulfillment location, manpower, packaging materials, and shipping charges.

We’ll use the example of a business that offers modest, durable home products with an average monthly volume of 240 orders to show how this works. This case-study shop is operated out of a leased storage container by a single person (that is, an owner without hired staff).

Storage, labor, packing materials, and shipment are the four key cost components to consider in an in-house fulfillment operation. In the case above, total monthly fulfillment expenses are estimated to be $4,100.

Let’s look at how to tackle each cost center evaluation in more detail:

Costs of Storage and Facilities

Depending on your location and space requirements, this cost might vary significantly. There must be enough room to store products, process/package orders, and accommodate employees.

Many solopreneurs begin their businesses from their homes. If your inventory and order volume are modest enough to remain out of the way of occupying the area, this is a viable solution. However, when your company grows, you’ll need to expand your facilities, which normally involves moving to an offsite warehouse or storage unit.

Here’s a breakdown of the prices for those options:

Home-based fulfillment

If you want to work from a place currently accessible in your house (such as a guest bedroom or garage), you’ll need to figure out how much it will cost you to do so. Cleaning supplies, minor repairs, painting, and lighting accessories may all be added up.

Add in recurrent costs like extra power and temperature control over and above what you’d ordinarily pay for a home.

Offsite Workspace Rental

A medium-sized storage container, which offers roughly 200-300 square feet of working area, is a popular self-managed fulfillment facility. Because orders are often handled from the facility on a daily basis, owners typically pick a site near to their house.

This setting costs $160 per month on average, including electricity. A typical layout may include a couple of rows of shelves and a tiny packing table—enough space for one person and a strong inventory of small products.

If you need temperature control, your unit will cost 20 percent to 50 percent more.

For higher-volume firms, larger, industrial warehouse facilities are a preferable option—especially if you’ll need to hire additional employees or keep huge products. There are many additional factors in these buildings, including amenities, loading bays, fire-proofing systems, and location. The average monthly rental rate for a warehouse is Larger, industrial warehouse facilities are a better option for higher-volume businesses—especially if you’ll need to employ multiple staff members or store oversized inventory. These facilities have a lot more variables such as amenities, loading bays, fire-proofing systems, and location. The average base cost for renting a warehouse is $0.65-$0.87 per square foot/month..65-Larger, industrial warehouse facilities are a better option for higher-volume businesses—especially if you’ll need to employ multiple staff members or store oversized inventory. These facilities have a lot more variables such as amenities, loading bays, fire-proofing systems, and location. The average base cost for renting a warehouse is $0.65-$0.87 per square foot/month..87 per square foot.

Call a few neighboring storage facilities or small warehouse business parks and compare prices to acquire an accurate storage or warehouse pricing in your region.

Security cameras, on-site management, truck access, and maintenance services are all things to inquire about. Keep in mind that, in addition to monthly rent, you may need to factor in utilities, insurance, and taxes—especially if you’re renting a bigger warehouse-style apartment.

Labor

Aside from money, your time is the most important investment you can make when beginning a company. To fairly evaluate fulfillment options, you’ll need to figure out how much of your time would be spent on fulfillment if you handled the job yourself.

Keeping Track of Time

First, calculate how much time fulfillment will take on a weekly basis.

Make sure your cost just includes fulfillment duties; marketing, website development, and negotiating with suppliers are all things you’ll perform regardless of whether you opt to outsource fulfillment, so keep them out of your calculations.

Typical fulfillment responsibilities include:

• Getting to know delivery drivers
• Incoming cargo are received.
• Receiving goods and inspecting and stacking them
• Online orders are reviewed, processed, and printed.
• Product selection
• Orders for packing
• Shipping label processing and printing
• Meeting with delivery drivers OR dropping out things oneself
• Shipping boxes, tape, and packaging materials are ordered and stocked.
• Assurance of high quality
• Returns processing

All of these duties may take 4-5 hours per day, 5 days per week during the initial period. Of course, this is dependent on the volume and procedures of your orders.

Furthermore, certain items are more difficult to handle (and hence take longer) than others. Fulfilling requests for furniture or beds, for example, involves more effort than managing school supplies. Be honest with yourself about how long your processes will take and how much you can get done on your own.

Defining Worth

Next, calculate the cost of fulfillment labor.

As a startup managing fulfillment in-house, you’ll probably perform a lot of it yourself, if not all of it. So, even if you don’t accept money from the firm yet, you must assign a monetary value to your time. This is the only method to compare the prices of in-house vs outsourced fulfillment accurately.

When comparing in-house fulfillment versus using a fulfillment center, there are two methods to look at the cost of your own labor:

1. Your time should be valued in the same way that you would be compensated elsewhere. What would you earn if you were a salaried employee rather than establishing your own business? Try looking into earnings from your previous job, other jobs you could be doing at the same time, or the market hourly pay for someone with your degree and expertise.
2. Use the hourly rate you’d likely pay if you hired someone. This would most likely be part-time minimum-wage work for a beginning small firm. Check the Department of Labor’s website for your state’s minimum wage, and add a buffer to cover payroll expenses. A reasonable rule of thumb is to add further 25% to 40% to the worker’s pay.

I’m going to take the national average minimum wage ($9.56) plus a 30% increase for payroll expenditures ($2.87) for our comparison. The result is a wage of $12.43 per hour.

Costs of Packaging Materials

This is a price that fluctuates a lot based on what you’re shipping. Packaging expenses might be low if you offer tiny, lightweight items that don’t break readily. However, if you need specialized packaging to safeguard delicate items in transportation or you’re starting a branded program with unique boxes, packing may be extremely costly. In certain circumstances, a seasoned fulfillment center can help you save money on packing.

Check out our guide for more information on bespoke box and packing alternatives (including pricing and vendors).

We’ll utilize the packaging technique of a typical bare-bones company for our cost comparison. This features five distinct unbranded small-to-medium boxes, all of which may be purchased in bulk from Uline.

Blank newspaper is a common and economical solution for dunnage.

These supplies cost about $300 in total for a business that ships 225-250 orders each month.

What If I Told You…

For Priority Mail mailings, the USPS provides complimentary boxes. Priority Mail is a cost-effective delivery method for goods weighing less than 2 pounds, so this choice may save you money on packing for small, light items.

Costs and Shipping Options

One of the most significant expenses for every ecommerce company is shipping. What you sell, where you purchase it, how you ship, and where you ship from will all affect your shipping costs. Once you’ve got these variables dialed in to a predictable degree, the prices associated with them should be simple to anticipate.

However, without significant shipment experience, generating an estimate of your delivery costs might be difficult. One of the largest and most typical errors made by new small company owners, according to Anthony Watson of ShipBob, is not budgeting enough for transportation.

“Transportation expenses vary depending on a variety of circumstances,” he advises, “but a fair rule of thumb is to predict 20% of total sales.”

Remember to account for all of your shipping expenditures, not only outward shipping prices. The cost of transporting your goods from your suppliers to your fulfillment center must be included in.

A budgeting mistake here may wreak havoc on your financial flow—or, worse, ruin your nascent business. Below, we’ll look at several methods for estimating both outgoing and incoming shipping expenses.

Costs of Outbound Shipping Estimation

The delivery charges for each purchase are determined by four factors:

• Dimensions of the package
• the weight of the package
• The distance between you and your goal
• Service/delivery speed (Standard, Expedited, etc.)

The first two elements are already known if all of your purchases arrive in a standard box size and weight (such as a monthly subscription box or packed goods). In this instance, the shipping estimate tools on the UPS, FedEx, and USPS websites may help you estimate your shipping costs to various locations. If you provide multiple delivery options to your consumers, you may figure out expenses from there as well.

If you offer a range of products, the size and weight of your boxes will fluctuate from order to order. These expenses are more difficult to forecast, but you may make accurate approximations by sampling a variety of box weights and dimensions. Then, using the rate calculators on the carrier websites, determine an average of a range of charges.

For the sake of this case study, we’ll assume that shipping costs each purchase average $10.50. Shipping expenses would be $2,520 per month based on an average of 240 orders per month.

Inbound Shipping Costs Must Be Considered

Retailers often include incoming stock delivery charges in their total cost-of-goods calculations. So, if shipping a bulk purchase of 100 units to your location costs $30, each item will cost A common practice is for retailers to incorporate inbound stock shipping costs into their total cost-of-good numbers. So if a bulk order of 100 units costs $30 to ship to your location, each unit has a shipping cost of $0.30..30 to send.

This implies the total cost-of-goods may be set at $2.30 if the item costs $2 + This means if the item costs you $2 plus $0.30 on average to bring it in from your supplier, the total cost-of-good can be set at $2.30. This is a simple way to include inbound shipping in your product costs, but it can be inexact if your supplier’s shipping rates vary..30 on average to bring in from your supplier. This is a straightforward technique to incorporate inbound delivery charges in your product pricing, but it might be inaccurate if your supplier’s shipping rates differ.

You may compute the average cost of carrying a cargo and multiply it by the number of bulk orders you get per month if you have an incoming shipping history to draw on. This approach gives you a precise amount that you may include into your overall shipping costs.

Total Costs of In-House Fulfillment

Our total amounted to $4,100 each month, or $17.08 per order, when we added up storage, labor, packing, and shipping, then divided by the number of orders dispatched in a typical month.

That may seem like an expensive price, but compare that to the average retail price of $60:

The average product cost is 50%, resulting in a gross profit of $30 per purchase. After fulfillment charges of $17.08 each order, the cost per order is $12.92, or $3,100 per month.

Once you’ve calculated your own fulfillment costs, compare them to your typical sales and gross profits, like we did before, to see how lucrative your model is.

For our case-study scenario, let’s compare these figures to the cost of a fulfillment facility. We already know it will save time—in my case, roughly 22.5 hours each week.

How to Calculate Your Fulfillment Partner’s Costs

While fulfillment firms do not have uniform pricing, the most of them have a comparable cost structure. The following are the key expenses of outsourced fulfillment:

• Fees for product storage (charged per pallet or bin, depending on quantity of unique SKUs)
• Receiving inbound shipments (charged per hour of labor)
• Fee for choosing products from inventory and packaging them for shipping as part of a combined fulfillment service (charged per item)
• Fees for specialized services (optional amenities)

Onboarding fees and monthly account management fees are charged by certain firms, however many high-quality partners will not charge you for these services.

The cost of these procedures is determined by the fulfillment business you choose. It’s a good idea to search around before deciding on a fulfillment partner if you’re considering outsourcing fulfillment. Any firm will provide you a free quotation based on a few basic facts about your organization.

Alternatively, fulfillment brokers such as FulfillmentCompanies.net can match your requirements with 500+ pre-screened partners, and the service is completely free.

For this comparison, we’ll utilize ShipBob, one of our preferred fulfillment partners. It caters to small enterprises and startups and provides free onboarding as well as no monthly minimums.

Read our review of ShipBob for more details.

Costs for ShipBob based on our criteria:

Comparing Prices

Total monthly fulfillment in-house: $4,100 – $2,814 per month in ShipBob fulfillment ShipBob saves $1,286 each month.

That’s a $5.35 per package save, or a total yearly savings of $15,408—a reasonable sum. As a result, outsourcing fulfillment for our case study scenario not only frees up time but also saves a lot of money.

Benefits Comparison

When it comes to setting the basis for a long-term endeavor, money isn’t always the most important aspect to consider. This is particularly true for ecommerce organizations, which must consider the impact of each aspect on the client experience.

Here are some of the most important factors to consider while choosing a fulfillment strategy:

Orders are your sole physical contact with your ecommerce clients, therefore providing a great experience is critical to building a successful business.

Service-level agreements (also known as SLAs) and other assurances guaranteed in the contract you’ll sign during onboarding safeguard the service you (and your customers) get from a partner fulfillment firm.

However, since 3PLs are high-volume procedures, faults are certain to occur. Additionally, any alterations or extra touches you want to incorporate must be coordinated with the fulfillment center’s employees. If this happens often, it may be inconvenient and time-consuming.

In-house fulfillment is likely ideal for you if you hand create things or modify your products, and each stage demands a human touch. If, on the other hand, your items are essentially box-and-send, consider hiring a professional.

When you operate an in-house business, a large portion of your shipping expenses will be determined by your location in proximity to your consumers.

A Seattle warehouse can easily service a West Coast client base, but delivering goods to New York is a different problem.

If you have orders coming in from all over the county (or from foreign purchasers), a fulfillment supplier with many key locations will get your products into the hands of your consumers much faster—and for less money. To ensure effective delivery to your consumers, you might keep your merchandise in various warehouses.

ShipBob’s 16 total fulfillment facilities are shown on a map (Source: ShipBob)

A large fulfillment network won’t help you as much if your consumer base is largely local. In this situation, in-house fulfillment is a fine option—until you wish to broaden your reach.

If your company operates on a small scale, with just a few orders coming in each week, an in-house fulfillment operation is likely your best choice.

Despite the fact that ShipBob has no minimum order limit, most fulfillment providers will only deal with merchants that handle a particular volume each month. The usual criterion seems to be between 200 and 400 orders per month, however other organizations limit their services to retailers who sell 1,000 or more items per month.

At the same time, it’s critical to be ready to handle increased order volume around the holidays or throughout the school-shopping season.

As an in-house business, you’ll almost certainly need to enlarge your physical space, add seasonal assistants, and prepare for an onslaught of non-fulfillment requests (like customer service and product sourcing). When company slows down after yearly sales surges, you may find yourself with an excess of resources but not enough money to pay for them.

Fast growth and seasonal surges are no problem for a fulfillment partner. They always have extra infrastructure on hand, and you’re only paying for what you really use. One of the most significant benefits of outsourcing fulfillment is the ability to expand and contract quickly.

If you’re new to ecommerce, a fulfillment partner can walk you through the process and help you avoid the pitfalls that many small businesses and startups make.

Because fulfillment firms bill customers based on consumption, your success is inextricably related to their success. This is beneficial to new company owners, who may benefit from the staff’s extensive ecommerce and shipping experience while they manage their own development.

However, if you prefer to fulfill your orders in-house, you may find it to be a very fulfilling experience. Hands-on experience is the only way to properly grasp the process, including its costs and opportunities for improvement.

Plus, if you decide to outsource fulfillment later, you’ll be better equipped to ask the necessary questions and examine expenses with a critical eye.

Consider how you want to spend your time while developing your satisfaction strategy.

Do you want to be in charge of stocking items, processing orders, packaging boxes, and printing shipping labels, or do you want to supervise others? Or would you rather spend your time promoting your online brand, expanding your product range, and growing your business?

Both strategies have benefits and may be used in various phases of company growth. However, for many businesses, the chance to drive development via brand promotion is what makes outsourced fulfillment attractive.

Conclusion

Getting things into the hands of consumers is at the core of every ecommerce firm.

You may have a well-designed website, enticing product offerings, excellent customer service, and efficient marketing campaigns—but if you can’t get orders out the door in a timely and cost-effective way, your firm won’t last long. As a result, deciding on a fulfillment plan is critical.

The easiest method to decide the optimal plan for your company is to evaluate the costs and advantages of managing fulfillment in-house and compare them to an outsourced solution. To save money, refocus your time, and promote profitable development, we suggest working with a third-party fulfillment service for most small companies.

You Might Also Enjoy…

The “fedex fulfillment pricing” is a service that is provided by FedEx. This service allows companies to ship their items to the FedEx fulfillment center for distribution and then have them delivered to their customers.

Related Tags

• average fulfillment cost per order
• 3pl fees and rates
• ecommerce fulfillment pricing
• 3pl cost per pallet
• apparel fulfillment pricing